5-Day Forecast
Brown signs EU Treaty as experts warn UK will surrender control of immigration
Last updated at 17:36 13 December 2007
Comments (
Add to My Stories
Gordon Brown finally signed the Lisbon treaty this afternoon - nearly three hours after every other EU leader.
With charges of "gutlessness" ringing in his ears before he set off, the Prime Minister suffered more indignity when a TV link crashed just as he was about to put his name on the document.
In the end his signature had to be squeezed alongside that of David Miliband, the Foreign Secretary, who earlier acted as stand-in for the Premier for a glitzy signing ceremony, joined by leaders of the other 26 EU member states.
Scroll down for more...
Hours after everyone else Gordon Brown finally signs the EU ReformTreaty
Wearing a dark suit and pale tie, Mr Brown signed up at around 3.15pm, watched by EC president Jose Manuel Barroso and the Portuguese premier Jose Socrates.
The Prime Minister signed despite new evidence which shows the controversial document will surrender almost all control of Britain's immigration
Due to the delayed arrival of Mr Brown, Foreign Secretary David Miliband was the only foreign minister to attend the televised ceremony alone, amid a stream of prime ministers and presidents from the other 26 EU states.
Buried in the Treaty's small print is a ruling that gives new rights to EU leaders to overturn decisions made by Britain's Immigration and Asylum Tribunal.
Done deal: British Foreign Secretary David Miliband puts pen to paper and signs the controversial treaty on behalf of the UK
Thousands of failed asylum seekers will now be able to take their cases to the European Court of Justice in Strasbourg where the final say will be handed to unselected bureaucrats in Brussels.
European Union leaders began signing the treaty at noon today in Lisbon - with Gordon Brown, who is flying in later today, expected to sign at about 3pm.
Portuguese Prime Minister Jose Socrates, whose country holds the rotating EU presidency, said the treaty would create a more modern, more efficient and more modern union.
"The world needs a stronger Europe," he said.
In a speech before the signing, European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso called on European leaders to use the treaty to make freedom, prosperity and solidarity an everyday reality for all European citizens.
"From this old continent, a new Europe is born," he said.
Neil O'Brien, who heads the I Want A Referendum campaign, claimed last night: "By signing us up to the rejected Constitution, Gordon Brown is giving EU courts the right to hear asylum cases.
"This could mean that decisions made by UK courts to deport failed asylum seekers will be overturned by Brussels."
Almost 170,000 deportation cases are already brought before the Immigration Tribunal every year, with each case usually lasting around two years.
Giving failed asylum seekers powers to take their cases to Europe will cost the taxpayer millions of extra pounds as each case now already costs an average of £18,000.
The move drew a furious reaction from Tory leader David Cameron who has accused the Prime Minister of "betraying" the British public after ditching plans to hold a referendum.
Scroll down for more ...
'From this old continent, a new Europe is born': European Commission Jose Manuel Barroso speaks at the signing
"Today Gordon Brown will betray every good thing he claimed to stand for when he became Prime Minister," Cameron told the Sun.
"He said he would trust the British people and consult them more. He doesn't even have the guts to put it to the British people."
The news emerged after Brown was accused of political cowardice after it was confirmed that he will miss today's lavish signing ceremony for the new European treaty.
He will arrive in Lisbon too late and will have to add his name some time after the other EU leaders.
Tories seized on the announcement as evidence that Mr Brown is trying to duck responsibility for a treaty that he personally supports.
He has repeatedly stated that the delay is due to a diary conflict - but as he appeared before a House parliamentary committee today he opened with a joking reference to his plan to miss the signing ceremony and the EU heads of state family photo, so that he could appear before the committee.
"I think you can see the priority I attach to attending this committee," he said.
Shadow Foreign Secretary William Hague said: "Some people say Gordon Brown's problems are that he isn't decisive and he lacks political courage.
"If he's ashamed of signing this treaty then why doesn't he honour his election promise and let the British people have their say?"
Scroll down for more ...
Dead end: Referendum campaigners display their spoof signs
However, the Prime Minister dismissed the row over his decision not to attend the ceremony saying he had a prior engagement appearing before MPs at the Commons Liaison committee in Westminster.
Downing Street said that despite his late arrival in Lisbon, cameras will still be present when he finally adds his signature to the treaty more than an hour after EU leaders. He will then carry out talks with EU president Jose Socrates.
The Reform Treaty, negotiated earlier this year by Tony Blair and endorsed by Mr Brown, replaces the planned constitution that was rejected by voters in France and Holland in 2005.
Labour's 2005 manifesto pledged to give British voters a referendum on the constitution, but Mr Brown insists the treaty is substantially different.
But a string of other EU leaders have admitted it is almost identical to the proposed 2005 constitution, on which Labour promised a referendum before it was rejected by voters in France and Holland.
Yesterday, furious British Euro MPs led a noisy protest at a signing ceremony for a new EU rights charter. Around 100 heckling Eurosceptics from Britain, France, Poland and Italy wrecked what was supposed to be a solemn event at the Strasbourg Parliament.
Scroll down for more ...
'Treaty of Lisbon': Flags pronouncing the EU treaty's name in 15 different languages are being placed around the monastery where it will be signed
They waved placards and banners, stamped, booed and chanted "referendum". Opponents called them "hooligans" who shamed Britain.
The ceremony at the parliament was held to mark the signing of the charter by the EU's three institutions - the European Parliament, European Commission and the European Council, which represents the member states.
"Referendum, we want a referendum. The people of Europe deserve to decide for themselves," Nigel Farage, leader of Britain's UK Independence Party, shouted from his seat.
Labour and Liberal Democrat MPs in marginal seats face fierce attacks at the next election over their refusal to back a referendum on the revised EU constitution.
Millions of leaflets will be sent to voters in the constituencies of 101 Labour and 30 LibDem MPs with majorities under 5,000.
They will accuse the MPs of treating the public like "fools".
Organisers of the ReferendumList.com campaign say even a small backlash could unseat many of the anti-referendum MPs.
Just in case: Two of the guardians of the 'Book of the Lisbon Treaty of Jeronimos Monastery' are pictured with exact copies of the treaty - just in case anything happens to the original
Print this article
Read later
Email to a friendFEMAIL TODAY
icon below an article to save to your favourite stories fileToday's headlines
Most Read
- Girl, 3, survives after being sucked down drain, carried 75 yards underground and thrown out into river
- Eight die in floods as cost of clean-up hits 'tens of millions' - and there's MORE to come
- Computer crash halts trading on London Stock Exchange - after shares soar in wake of U.S. cash bail-out
- U.S. mortgage giant bail-out could give British homeowners hope of cheaper loans
- More pressure on household budgets as food prices jump to record levels
- Ex-boyfriend of Shannon Matthews' mother 'had over 100 indecent images of children on his computer'
- Mother fails her driving test - for splashing man at bus stop
- The 'double glazing Queen' who was sacked for daring to have two children in 14 months
- Health and safety bosses refuse to cut grass verge - because it's on a slope
- Man charged with murder of couple 'stabbed to death on canal boat in middle of night'
- Nanny to the stars jailed after leaving baby brain-damaged in 'act of genuine cruelty'
- Family face losing their home after 'mistake by mobile phone company ruined their credit rating'
- Miliband finally gives Brown his support - but hints he has failed to deliver so far as Cabinet meets in Birmingham
- Pay workers more or face winter of discontent: Unions throw down gauntlet to Brown
- Boy, 13, bullied after losing his hair is banned from wearing a baseball cap to school
- You're booked! Police hand out yellow cards to rowdy drinkers banning them from the area
- Scientists receive death threats over Big Bang experiment from critics who fear end of the world
- Revealed: Shocking footage that could prove that 90 Afghans - not seven - died in U.S. airstrike
- Teaching correct spelling is a waste of time - and the apostrophe should be scrapped, says expert
- British millionaire behind bars after 'trying to set fire to his fiancée' at their Spanish villa
- Pictured: The horrific bus and tram pile-up which left one man dead
- Dentist who told mouth cancer victim to gargle with Listerine allowed to carry on practising
- Anti-obesity jab that will stop you feeling hungry 'available within five years'
- Girl, 11, choked to death on piece of chicken after 'ambulance went to wrong street'
- UK should be given special opt-out deals from EU, says author of EU constitution Giscard d'Estaing
- MORE HEADLINES
- Eight die in floods as clean-up costs hit 'tens of millions' - and there is MORE to come
- Suspect charged with murder of man and woman 'stabbed to death on canal boat in middle of the night'
- Sales queen sacked for daring to have children in line for £200,000 compensation
- British millionaire behind bars after 'trying to set fire to his fiancée' at their Spanish villa
- Family faces losing their home after credit rating blunder by mobile phone firm
- Man dies after horrific bus and tram pile-up
- Girl, 3, survives after being sucked down drain, carried 75 yards underground and thrown out into river
- Computer crash halts London Stock Exchange as trading soars following U.S. cash bail-out
- Celebrity healer to the stars sued by patient who 'needed double leg amputation after treatment'
- All-party call for 20,000-a-year cap on migrants arriving in UK
- Labrador survives being hit by express train 'after his wounds are healed instantly by heat from engine'
- Landlady ordered to pay damages to serial rapist for clearing his flat after arrest
- Mother fails her driving test - for splashing man at bus stop
- MELANIE PHILLIPS: Contempt, apathy and lies - why Britain is crying out for a 'pitbull with lipstick'
- U.S. mortgage giant bail-out could give British homeowners hope of cheaper loans
- Mighty Murray aims to muscle his way into British tennis history with a historic Grand Slam win over Federer
- Apple admit Briton DID invent iPod, but he's still not getting any money
- Miliband finally gives Brown his support but suggests he has failed to deliver so far as Cabinet meets in Birmingham
- Justice at last? 13 years after he was cleared of murder, OJ Simpson is back in court accused of kidnap and robbery
- 'Stress' kills the mother of tragic TV star Speight
- MOST READ IN DETAIL
Comments (124)
Here's what readers have had to say so far. Why not add your thoughts below?
I'm sorry to disabuse your hope, but Canada is undergoing the EXACT same process - with the EXACT same reaction from our PMs and PRESS/media. This is a world-wide full-court press! Are our PMs ALL bought or afraid? The silence is deafening! God save us from the machinations of the World Banksters and the foul ELITE dream of A Brave New Feudalism!
- John, Scarborough Canada, 14/12/2007 00:59
Time for a vote of no confidence, get behind another poll tax march type stance against these commies to get them out NOW!! People power!
- Steve, New Zealand, 14/12/2007 00:51
We do not control immigration now, so why the fuss? The Labour policy seems to be let them come in, regardless of whether they have any skills or education. We won't notice any difference at all, expect of course the lawyers representing these people who doubtless will now be even richer.
- Diana, Staffs, 14/12/2007 00:39
**yourComments**
- **name**, **townAndCountry**, **creationDate**
Add your comment